Finding The Best Rolex Datejust Of All ime — Which One Gets Your Vote?
The Rolex Datejust is arguably the most versatile and enduring watch in the Genevan brand’s lineup. This year marks the 80th anniversary of the model, so we decided to mark the occasion. Over the past few weeks, members of our editorial team have shared their favorite Datejust references. Now it’s time to gather them all in one place, revisit our writers’ choices, and ask you, our readers, to crown the ultimate Datejust. From archetypal icons to quirky outliers, these seven picks show just how wide the Datejust spectrum truly is. Which one will stand above the rest?
Thomas — The archetypal Rolex Datejust 1601
For Thomas, the Datejust is at its strongest when it embodies simplicity. His pick, the 1601, represents everything the model should be — clean, balanced, and timeless. With its fluted bezel, pie-pan dial, and Jubilee bracelet, the 1601 distills the Datejust down to its most essential and recognizable form. For Thomas, this reference is the “king” of the line because it delivers enduring elegance without leaning on flashy materials or bold experimentation.
Mike — The 1601 with a lavender dial
Mike Stockton leaned into character with his pick, a 1601 featuring a rare no-lume lavender dial. It’s a perfect example of how the Datejust can surprise even seasoned collectors. The subtle pastel tone lends a unique personality, softening the watch’s otherwise formal demeanor. The no-lume execution keeps the look understated yet distinctive, and in a collection overflowing with traditional dials, this one stands out as something quietly special.
Image: Amsterdam Vintage Watches
Jorg — A white gold 16019 with a burl wood dial
Jorg took a different path, spotlighting the 36mm white gold Datejust with a burl wood dial. To him, it’s about turning the Datejust’s visual brilliance up to eleven. The warm, organic wood patterns paired with precious metal elevate the Datejust beyond its tool-watch roots. It shows the line’s capacity for experimentation and refinement, and for Jorg, it represents the Datejust at its most extravagant and visually captivating.
Image: Wind Vintage
Daan — The one that doesn’t exist (yet) or a yellow gold 16078
Daan played provocateur, admitting that his favorite Datejust doesn’t technically exist. Instead, he outlined a dream reference — a blend of current and past elements that would make his ideal daily wearer. In the meantime, he highlighted a few close contenders, references that nearly deliver on his vision. His contribution underscores how the Datejust inspires wish-casting as much as admiration, and his “non-pick” adds a playful but thoughtful angle to this lineup. That said, we’ll have his contender be his favorite from the options he presents, namely, the 16078 in yellow gold.
Rolex Datejust 16234 with a tapestry dial, ca. 1991 — Image: Langedyk Vintage Watches
RJ — The Datejust 16234
RJ zeroed in on the 16234, a model he argues “ticks all the boxes.” With its white-gold fluted bezel, reliable movement, and classic proportions, the 16234 represents the peak of Datejust utility and collectibility. It’s modern enough to be practical and vintage enough to carry charm. RJ’s case for this watch is rooted in balance. It isn’t flashy, but it’s thoroughly satisfying, a model that exemplifies why the Datejust continues to endure decade after decade.
Picture courtesy of Swiss Watch Expo
Lex — The Datejust Turn-O-Graph 116263
Lex went off the beaten path, opting for the two-tone Turn-O-Graph ref. 116263. Though technically a spin-off of the Datejust, he argues that this “adopted” member deserves recognition. With its rotating bezel and blend of sporty and dressy cues, the Turn-O-Graph injects utility into the otherwise straightforward Datejust DNA. For Lex, that blend of versatility and heritage makes it his favorite. It’s a bold choice, highlighting just how broad the Datejust family can be.
Image: Bulang & Sons
Nacho — Discovering the 16014 with a champagne dial
Nacho’s contribution differs slightly from the others because it started with uncertainty. He admitted he didn’t have a favorite Datejust — until writing about it made him find one. His criteria were strict — a quick-set date, plexiglass, Jubilee bracelet, 36mm case, and stainless steel. After ruling out near-misses, like the 16000, Nacho finally landed on the 16014. With its steel case, white-gold fluted bezel, and champagne dial, it struck the balance he’d been looking for. He admits this combination skirts the two-tone line but finds its understated charm irresistible. For Nacho, the 16014 is the watch that finally gave him his “Datejust moment.”
Time to vote!
Seven editors, seven interpretations of the Rolex Datejust. Now it’s over to you. Which one best captures the essence of this enduring Rolex classic? Cast your vote in the poll below to help us decide which Datejust reigns supreme.
