Sunday Morning Showdown: Breitling Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41 Vs. Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch
It’s Sunday morning, which means it’s time for another one of our weekly showdowns. This week, two legendary hand-wound chronographs go head to head. Nacho picked the Breitling Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41, which recently joined the brand’s core collection at €7,450 on a leather strap or €7,800 on a steel bracelet. It faces the Hesalite version of the Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch, which costs €7,700. With similar price tags and places among the industry’s biggest icons, these two chronographs make for an intriguing matchup. Which one will come out on top? You decide!
When Breitling unveiled the new Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41 and the Navitimer B02 Chronograph 41 Cosmonaute a few weeks ago, fans were excited to see modern interpretations of two brand classics. Both take inspiration from 1960s models and bring back the Twin Jet logo on the dial. Nacho picked the Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41 for this week’s battle against Jorg and the Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch. Introduced in January 2021, the current Moonwatch has spent almost six years in the collection without losing its appeal. Jorg chose the Hesalite version, which comes closest to the watch that landed on the Moon. It promises to be an epic battle!
Last week, on Sunday Morning Showdown…
First, let’s look at last week’s results. The Panerai Submersible Marina Militare Destro PAM01757 beat the Omega Seamaster Ploprof 1200M Summer Blue in a closer contest than some had expected. The Panerai took 54% of the votes, leaving the Omega with 46%. The comments suggested that most readers preferred the Panerai’s looks to the Ploprof’s unusual shape. One thing was clear, though: fans of the quirky, oversized Omega are passionate about it. Hopefully, we’ll see the same enthusiasm in this week’s matchup. Over to Jorg and Nacho!
Jorg: Omega Speedmaster Professional 310.30.42.50.01.001
As we are in Speedmaster Central here at Fratello, I’ll spare you the standard details about the current Moonwatch. If you’re a regular reader, you’ve probably seen plenty of our articles about Omega’s world-famous chronograph. Almost six years after the current model’s introduction, it remains as relevant as ever.
At its current price, the Speedmaster is still the best chronograph your money can buy. The Breitling Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41 doesn’t change that. Still, it’s nice to see the classic hand-wound Navitimer return to Breitling’s collection. It feels like something the brand should have done sooner, but it’s better late than never!
The Speedmaster has the better design
What makes the Speedmaster the better watch for me? It starts with the design. The Moonwatch looks far more appealing, and I think we should give the Omega designers of the late 1950s more credit. Chronographs are notoriously difficult to design because they have so many elements to balance. The result can be awkward register placement, cut-off numerals, and other visual compromises. The Moonwatch avoids those pitfalls. Its balanced layout and excellent proportions make it feel just right.
While Breitling’s designers did a good job of incorporating pilot-focused functionality into the Navitimer, it has too many visual elements that make it hard to process. Four scales, including the famous slide rule, sit outside the hour markers. The Speedmaster’s tachymeter bezel frees up space on the dial, allowing the two scales to sit neatly alongside the hour markers and seconds track. Ultimately, I simply prefer the Speedy’s cleaner look.
The Speedmaster is the better daily watch
The Moonwatch’s superior readability also makes it more practical for daily wear. The contrast between its black dial and bezel and its white hands makes everything easy to read. The Navitimer also uses a black-and-white palette, but its dial is much harder to navigate. And, Nacho, I’ve always thought its hands were too short for the dial. Once you notice that, it’s hard to ignore, even considering the practical reason behind their length.
Practicality also comes down to wearability, and the Speedmaster wins here, too. The modern Moonwatch bracelet strikes an excellent balance between solid construction and flexibility. It also looks particularly good on the Hesalite version, which lacks the polished intermediate links found on the sapphire model.
The Moonwatch looks equally at home on Omega’s coated nylon strap. In fact, almost any strap works with it. The Navitimer is less versatile. It looks great on leather, but the bracelet, with its diagonal links, doesn’t appeal to me. Its comfort also falls short of the Speedmaster bracelet.
I prefer the Omega caliber 3861
The movement also plays an important part in a watch’s suitability for daily wear. Breitling’s caliber B09 has the advantage of traditional chronograph architecture, with a column wheel and vertical clutch. But when it comes to a dependable chronograph movement, I prefer Omega’s 3861. It is the modern successor to the 1861 movement, which established an excellent reliability record in the Speedmaster.
The biggest updates to the 3861 were its Co-Axial escapement and Master Chronometer certification, which demonstrate Omega’s efforts to improve accuracy and magnetic resistance. As Robert-Jan explained in his comparison of the previous and current Moonwatch, Omega made 50% of the 3861’s parts non-interchangeable with those of the earlier caliber. That shows the brand’s commitment to refining an already proven design.
After all, the Speedmaster still must meet the demanding standards associated with spaceflight, where reliability is essential. There’s some romance in that, of course, but the experiences of people around me have reinforced my confidence in the 3861.
The choice is easy for me
Ultimately, I’d choose the watch I want to wear more, and that’s an easy decision. I would spend my hard-earned €7,700 on the Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch 310.30.42.50.01.001 in a heartbeat. I like the new Breitling Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41 and respect its legacy, but it doesn’t inspire the same feeling. The Speedy is my clear pick in this week’s matchup. Now, Nacho, tell everyone why I’m wrong!
Nacho: Breitling Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41
Thanks, Jorg! Taking on Omega’s classic chronograph here at Fratello reminds me of that meme with the water polo player dumping a water bottle on his head. I once again find myself the underdog in one of these weekly matchups. Still, I’m not giving up just yet. I think there’s a chance, albeit a small one, that the Navitimer’s latest incarnation might tip the scales.
In my opinion, modern Navitimers have always stood in the shadow of the reference 806. Breitling produced that reference from the mid-1950s until the late ’60s or early ’70s, depending on whom you ask. Like the early Speedmaster, the Navitimer 806 had time to establish itself and become the quintessential version. Over the years, though, it spawned countless variations and became a platform for evolution and experimentation.
Unfortunately, the most modern iteration before this one — the B01 Navitimer 43, introduced in 2022 — didn’t quite get it right. It was still a Navitimer, but something was missing… Or perhaps it was the opposite. I’m sure I’m not the only one who thinks so.
In my eyes, the latest version, the Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41, is more of an 806 reissue. It’s a true return to form, bringing back much of what made the original great. In that respect, it accomplishes something similar to what Omega did with the 3861 Speedy a few years ago. And I think it finally gives the Navitimer a real chance against the Moonwatch.
Navitimer street cred
No watch can challenge the Speedmaster’s title as the first watch worn on the Moon. However, it wasn’t the only watch to make a name for itself during the golden age of aerospace. The Navitimer quickly became a trusted instrument among professional pilots. Its integrated circular slide rule allowed aviators to perform essential flight calculations, including fuel consumption, speed, and distance. Throughout the 1950s and ’60s, it helped establish Breitling’s reputation as a leading maker of pilot’s watches.
In 1962, the Navitimer also made it into space thanks to NASA astronaut Scott Carpenter. He approached Breitling to create a modified version for his Mercury-Atlas 7 mission aboard the Aurora 7 spacecraft. The resulting Navitimer Cosmonaute featured a 24-hour dial, allowing Carpenter to distinguish day from night while orbiting Earth. On May 24th, 1962, he completed three orbits wearing the watch, making it the first Swiss wristwatch in space.
So, the Navitimer’s similarities to the Speedy go beyond its three-register chronograph layout. It has a rich history and plenty of street cred, even if it takes a very different design approach. You could call it maximalist, but I’ve always found its information overload rather charming. It might make reading the time and timing events slightly more complicated, but I don’t see that as a drawback. The same goes for the “short hands” you mentioned, Jorg — although only the minute hand is guilty of that crime. In the context of the watch, neither hand looks particularly awkward or out of place to me.
A near-perfect reissue
There’s little to fault in the new Breitling Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41. It has no faux-aged lume, and its glossy black dial features beautiful printing and a golden Twin Jet logo. The slide-rule bezel turns with just the right amount of resistance. The proportions are spot-on, too. Its 41mm diameter, measured across the protruding bezel, doesn’t tell the whole story of its wearability. With a 13mm profile, it’s almost a millimeter slimmer than its predecessors.
You may have noticed that, even in the photos I took at the Breitling boutique in The Hague, the crystal is almost impossible to see. I honestly couldn’t tell you whether it was flat, domed, or even there! Joking aside, the domed sapphire crystal is one of the most transparent and unobtrusive I’ve encountered, even in challenging shooting conditions. With the Moonwatch, you have to choose between the milky ring around the sapphire crystal and the scratch-prone Hesalite alternative.
The bracelet, however, is a more modern creation, and as Jorg mentioned, it isn’t the watch’s strongest look. It doesn’t clash with the design, but the Navitimer clearly shines on a strap. If you agree, you can also save some money by choosing the leather option. I’d take the approach I used with my Nomos Club Sport Neomatik Worldtimer: buy the watch on the bracelet, wear it on a strap, and keep the bracelet around just in case.
The B09 movement
To wrap things up, let’s talk movements. Breitling’s B09 makes a strong case, combining traditional chronograph architecture with practical performance. Based on the brand’s in-house B01, it uses a column wheel and vertical clutch for precise, reliable operation. It also offers a 70-hour power reserve, comfortably exceeding the Omega 3861’s 50 hours. Both are hand-wound movements, but the B09’s longer reserve means you can leave the watch off your wrist for the weekend and expect it to still be running on Monday.
Furthermore, while Omega’s Co-Axial technology is impressive, its construction can make servicing more involved. The B09’s more traditional architecture may be more familiar to independent watchmakers, although servicing any modern chronograph movement still requires the appropriate expertise.
The column wheel and vertical clutch also provide a solid mechanical foundation and crisp chronograph engagement. As a COSC-certified chronometer, the B09 is no slouch when it comes to precision. The Omega 3861 counters with its Co-Axial escapement, METAS certification, and impressive magnetic resistance. Those advantages matter, but they don’t diminish the Breitling’s appeal.
Sure, Speedies have been tested in space and qualified by NASA. But let’s face it: most of us aren’t going to space anytime soon. For a traditional hand-wound chronograph, the Breitling offers a longer power reserve and proven architecture. I’d say that’s enough to give it the edge in this particular showdown.
Why the Navitimer deserves your vote
To me, the new B09 is truly exciting because it marks the symbolic return of a great Navitimer reference. We’ve had excellent Speedmasters for a long time, with an uninterrupted line stretching back to the first model in 1957. At this price point, though, I think the new Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41 deserves more than a place in the conversation about alternatives to the Moonwatch. It’s a serious contender in its own right.
Time to vote!
Now it’s your turn. Will you side with Jorg and the classic Omega Speedmaster Moonwatch, or will you back Nacho’s underdog pick, the Breitling Navitimer B09 Chronograph 41? Both watches have plenty to offer and share some common ground, but only one can emerge victorious. Cast your vote below, and may the best chronograph win!

























